Welcome to Sully's in the Valley
Sully's in the Valley, located at 5642 Beaver Pike in Beaver, Ohio, offers a delightful dining experience steeped in charm and nostalgia. This inviting eatery is known for its extensive menu featuring freshly prepared burgers, fire-brick oven pizzas, and delectable homemade sides like potato skins and pickle fries. The retro decor enhances the warm atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for families and friends alike. Whether indulging in a classic banana split or enjoying the friendly service, patrons leave raving about the quality and taste. Sully's is a must-visit for those seeking comfort food with a homey twist in a quaint setting.
Sully's in the Valley: Reviews & Ratings
Great little restaurant with reasonable prices! We had burgers, the homemade chips, pizza and shakes... all delicious! The retro decor was so neat, and the service was great. Highly recommend Sully’s... we’ll be coming back!
Great food, very clean, staff was friendly and helpful. Must recommend the banana split. We got hand dipped Perrys ice cream in our banana split black raspberry, study break, and banana cream pie with Carmel drizzle instead of hot fudge, delicious combo! Pizza was cooked in fire brick over very good crust. Highly recommend the potato skins.
We were in Beaver for a funeral and looking for a place to grab a bite to eat before driving home. I wanted something we can't get everywhere else or at home. This place was charming! It was a jump back in time with decor, music and even the "silent" TV playing Gunsmoke. Staff were helpful and friendly to out of towners. Menu had a variety of mains and sides plus ice cream! The table has real napkins and S&P shakers that work. Pepsi products, if it matters to you, and no adult beverages. My hubs ordered Bacon double cheeseburger and tater tots then 2 scoops of butter pecan ice cream in bowl. I ordered 8" pizza with onions in the sauce, pepperoni and mushrooms and a side of pickle fries!! OMGosh!!! The pickle fries are AMAZING! I wish I lived closer but it's a good thing I don't . The food was all steaming hot on arrival to our table.. Literally, My hubs had steam coming out of his burger after the first bite. Atmosphere was great.. Music was oldies and Chantilly Lace and Great Balls of Fire and the like played loud enough to hear but not so loud you couldn't carry on normal conversation. My only wish was for more kick in my pizza sauce but it won't stop me from returning if passing through this area of Route 32 again. It's across from a Marathon gas station so of you're near Beaver, Ohio and need gas... It's only a couple miles off the highway. PSA geta double order of pickle fries
Super friendly, super clean and super good fresh food! We had the hamburgers that are made from scratch. Photo is of Sully burger with coleslaw and it was super yummy! Bonus points for the toasted bun!! Gold bond malt completed this awesome lunch! We could tell the owner really cares about the food and the appearance of his place. Great stop!!
My wife my self and granddaughter love it we can go out set on the porch enjoy the small town atmosphere and have no worries of our granddaughter playing.Delicious food and the ice cream well none is better sorry everyone else your gonna have to step up your game!A or from us.
I live just down the road in Jackson, Ohio yet I’ve never heard of this place. Decided to give it a try and wasn’t disappointed. Great food and a great atmosphere. Large variety of menu options. Definitely will eat there again and try their pizza!
A Step Back in Time You’ll Never Forget Sully’s in the Valley is more than just a restaurant—it’s a time machine wrapped in chrome, neon lights, and the warmth of classic Americana. From the moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted with a 1950s/60s diner vibe that’s both authentic and inviting. The decor is perfectly retro, the music nostalgic, and the atmosphere is like something out of a dream. We stopped in recently for the first time, and it won’t be the last. The food? Absolutely incredible—flavorful, fresh, and clearly made with care. Every bite tasted like home. But what truly sets Sully’s apart is the people. The staff are friendly, passionate, and genuinely love what they do. We even had the pleasure of chatting with one of the owners, who shared stories about the restaurant’s history and its impact on the community. Sully’s isn’t just a place to eat. It’s a place to remember. If you’re ever in the area, do yourself a favor and experience it for yourself. It’s a hidden gem that deserves to be celebrated.
I’m from Cleveland on vacation near here and decided to try it. Food was amazing. Such a cool little small town. Would definitely come back. The food here was better than the “brass monkey” in Waverly that we spent over 100 on. Thank you !
Location
-
5642 Beaver Pike, Beaver, OH 45613, United States Hotline: +1 740-226-8292
Welcome to Sully's in the Valley, a culinary gem nestled in Beaver, Ohio at 5642 Beaver Pike. This charming restaurant captures both the heart and palate with its inviting atmosphere, delicious menu, and friendly service. Just a short drive from Route 32, it’s perfect for a quick stop or a leisurely meal with family and friends.
The moment you step inside, you're transported back in time. The retro decor, complete with nostalgic tunes playing softly in the background, creates a warm and cozy dining experience that’s as comforting as the food served. With glowing reviews from happy diners, it’s no wonder Sully’s is a much-loved spot among locals and visitors alike.
Let’s talk about the food! From hand-crafted burgers and flavorful pizzas cooked in a fire brick oven to unique sides like the sensational pickle fries, every dish is crafted with love and attention to detail. Diners rave about the homemade chips and the must-try banana split—a delightful treat made with hand-dipped Perrys ice cream, sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Patrons also recommend the potato skins and the chef's specialty, the Sully burger, noted for its freshly made patties and toasted buns.
One memorable dining experience shared by Melanie Tyler Davis depicts a lively atmosphere complemented by friendly staff who eagerly cater to your needs. Imagine enjoying a hot meal while listening to classics like "Chantilly Lace" and "Great Balls of Fire." The ambiance is casual yet inviting, making it a perfect stop for families. With Pepsi products available and no adult beverages, it's an excellent place for a guilt-free indulgence.
As you enjoy your meal, you’ll appreciate the cleanliness of the establishment and the attentive service that makes every guest feel valued. According to Mary Mahoney, the care taken by the owner in both food quality and restaurant aesthetics is clear—and it’s this kind of dedication that keeps return visitors coming back for more.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Sully's in the Valley is a spot you won't want to miss. Come and savor the delectable offerings, enjoy the quaint setting, and create memories while dining in a place that feels like home. Your taste buds will thank you!